Excessive Force Needed to Buckle Seat Belts – 2011 IC Bus BE, CE, & RE School Buses

June 21, 2019 NHTSA CAMPAIGN NUMBER: 19V478000

Excessive Force Needed to Buckle Seat Belts

The seat belt may not easily buckle, increasing the risk of an injury in the event of a crash.

 

NHTSA Campaign Number: 19V478

Manufacturer NavistareBay logo, Inc.

Components SEAT BELTS

Potential Number of Units Affected 1,035

 

Summary

NavistareBay logo, Inc. (NavistareBay logo) is recalling certain 2011 IC Bus BE, CE, and RE school buses equipped with certain non-retractable passenger two-point seat belts. After long term buckling and unbuckling of the seat belt, the plastic fingers on the male portion of the buckle may crack and fall off, requiring excessive force to buckle the seat belt.

 

Remedy

NavistareBay logo will notify owners and dealers will replace the seat belt assemblies, free of charge. NavistareBay logo issued owners an interim notification on August 16, 2019. The recall began September 23, 2019. Owners may contact NavistareBay logo customer service at 1-800-448-7825.

 

Notes

Owners may also contact the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration Vehicle Safety Hotline at 1-888-327-4236 (TTY 1-800-424-9153), or go to www.safercar.gov.

 


NHTSA is missing critical, required information for this safety recall. This information must be supplied through the NHTSA Recalls Portal within 5 working days of confirming its accuracy:

– An identification and description of the risk to motor vehicle safety reasonably related to the defect or noncompliance, as described by an increased risk of injury, fire or crash (49 CFR 573.6 (c)(5)).

– A description of the manufacturer’s program for remedying the defect or noncompliance (49 CFR 573.6 (c)(8)(i)).


  • 09/11/2018 NHTSA sends communication to NavistareBay logo advising that a VOQ had been submitted the agency regarding passenger two-point lap style seat belts in their CE buses.
  • 09/12/2018 NavistareBay logo starts the investigation on this issue; and contacts the customer to get the detailed information about the VOQ that was submitted to NHTSA.
  • 10/3/2018 Interim review of test findings to date which found multiple fractures observed around the radius of the plastic fingers.  And that there was a lack of deformation at any of the fracture locations, which indicate a brittle fracture.
  • 10/10/2018 NavistareBay logo updates NHTSA on the investigation regarding the total potential suspect population that were built with the finger design on the tongue side of the belt.
  • 10/17/2018 NavistareBay logo performed a local inspection at the Naperville school district in Illinois and inspected 7 buses with approximately 30 belts per bus.  Each bus had at least one or more plastic fingers missing on one of the belts, up to 7 belts with one or more broken plastic fingers.
  • 10/18/2018 Shield provided a third-party lab report from 2014 which indicated environmental stress cracking caused the plastic finger failures, because of a likely school district cleaning chemical which was not identified in the report.  The conclusion in that time frame was that the plastic finger failures on the tongue were maintenance related
  • 10/31/2018 NavistareBay logo received VIN information from State of New Jersey customer through a local dealer indicating they had 13 buses where several belts had broken plastic fingers on each bus.
  • 11/16/2018 Received report from third-party lab on request from NavistareBay logo to do environmental testing for root cause. The microscopic examination of the fracture surface features indicate that the ABS material failure is resulting from exposure to high mechanical loads experienced in service both from cyclic fatigue and assembly.
  • 1/9/2019 NavistareBay logo runs a seat belt tongue durability test. Seat belt buckles tested at 1 and 2 mm displacement passed the minimum cycle count requirement established by NavistareBay logo as 50,000 cycles without failure, buckles tested at 3 mm displacement did not meet the required cycle count.
  • 1/14/2019 NavistareBay logo performs a seat belt strain verses force test. The force and displacement required to achieve the proper strain was much higher than the force and displacement during durability testing. The conclusion was that these force and displacement numbers will not last the required number of cycles (50,000), since we observed failures at an average of 5,586 cycles with a 3 mm oscillating displacement.
  • 02/19/2019 NavistareBay logo receives PE18-015 from NHTSA
  • 02/20/2019 NavistareBay logo performs a fit evaluation study with students ranging in age from 6 to 14.  Peak strains were also measured.
  • 02/20/2019 – 04/01/19 NavistareBay logo gathers data and documents to respond to the inquiry.
  • 04/02/2019 NavistareBay logo submits PE18-015 response to NHTSA indicating that NavistareBay logo believes the issue with broken plastic fingers on the seat belt tongue cover for the applicable IC school buses does not pose an unreasonable risk of injury to the seat occupant in a vehicle crash on large school buses because the seating is designed for compartmentalization and is not dependent on the function of a seat belt.  Therefore, reported incidents would be handled as a customer satisfaction issue.
  • 04/02/2019 Received a test report from Shield after NavistareBay logo submitted the PE response.  First, they ran a test with a late suspect buckle (C3 version) at typical FMVSS 209 requirements. Then they ran an abuse scenario that applied forces to the tongue without the buckle to allow excessive movement of the fingers at 100% (30lbf), 133% (40lbf) and 200% (60lbf) of the FMVSS 209 force requirement. They indicated that all parts passed 200 cycles of preconditioning [S5.2 (g)] and post-performance testing [S4.2 (g)].
  • 04/24/2019 Shield ran a similar test to above with an earlier suspect buckle (C2 version) with similar results to the 4/2/19 test.
  • 05/01/2019 NavistareBay logo asked NHTSA on status of the investigation and NHTSA indicated they were analyzing the data.
  • 05/14/2019 Met with NHTSA ODI.  NHTSA disagreed with Navistars conclusions in response to PE18-015. They did share their analysis of the warranty and service part data. NHTSA recommended NavistareBay logo consider recalling certain buses.
  • 05/20/2019 NavistareBay logo met to review NHTSA data analysis.  Actions included looking at the warranty failure data from a statistical basis and also reviewing the data from a per belt failure rate basis.
  • 05/28/2019 NavistareBay logo and NHTSA ODI met again to review the per belt data.  There was no change in NHTSA direction because of the high service part usage even with low per belt warranty.
  • 06/03/2019 NavistareBay logo completed statistical study and discussed NHTSA rationale for performing a recall.  Concluded that the 2011 model year buses were statistically different than the other model years.
  • 06/10/2019 NavistareBay logo and NHTSA reviewed proposal to recall 2011 model year IC buses based on the higher warranty failure rate.
  • 06/12/2019 NavistareBay logo meets to review the above events. Because the seats in this application meet the compartmentalization requirements of FMVSS 222 without seat belts, agreement was reached to the above proposal pending finalizing the suspect population for the recall and the extending warranty for other model years.
  • 06/17/2019 NavistareBay logo declares a Safety Recall for 2011 model year IC buses.


3 Affected Products

Vehicles

IC BUSBE2011
IC BUSCE2011
IC BUSRE2011

 


12 Associated Documents

Defect Notice 573 Report

RCLRPT-19V478-8067.PDF 214.324KB

 


Recall Acknowledgement

RCAK-19V478-5962.pdf 245.73KB

 


Miscellaneous Document- Supplemental Chronology

RMISC-19V478-4457.pdf 36.821KB

 


Remedy Instructions and TSB

RCRIT-19V478-7115.pdf 2394.332KB

 


Recall Quarterly Report #2, 2019-4

RCLQRT-19V478-5500.PDF 211.234KB

 


Recall Quarterly Report #3, 2020-1

RCLQRT-19V478-9516.PDF 211.314KB

 


ISSUED Owner Notification Letter(Part 577)

RCONL-19V478-7895.pdf 509.471KB

 


Recall 573 Report- Amendment 1

RCLRPT-19V478-9585.PDF 215.964KB

 


Interim Owner Notification Letter(Part 577)- SPANISH

RIONL-19V478-5151.pdf 70.059KB

 


Interim Owner Notification Letter(Part 577)

RIONL-19V478-0789.pdf 31.694KB

 


Recall Quarterly Report #1, 2019-3

RCLQRT-19V478-1126.PDF 211.127KB

 


ISSUED Owner Notification Letter(Part 577)

RCONL-19V478-9818.pdf 945.382KB

 


Latest Recalls Documents

 


1 Associated Investigation

Lap seat belts fail to latch
NHTSA ID: PE18015
Dated opened: December 17, 2018

The Office of Defects Investigation (ODI) received a complaint from a school bus fleet in the state of New Jersey indicating seat belt failures in their model year 2015 school buses, built by NavistareBay logo, and equipped with Am Safe lap belts. The complaint states that the lap belt metal insert plastic cover breaks and prevents the insert from latching with the buckle. This fleet has replaced over 50 percent of the lap belts in their 8 buses. ODI reached out to Florida state school bus fleets to see if they had experienced the same problem since Florida is one of 6 states in the country requiring lap belts in their school buses. The state of Florida Director of Public School Bus Transportation contacted 20 municipalities and found maintenance records from 16 of the 20 fleets confirming seat belt buckle inserts broken in a similar fashion as those from New Jersey.

The following VOQ number is associated with the issues discussed in this opening resume: 11127877

A Preliminary Evaluation has been opened to evaluate the alleged defect conditions in the subject vehicles.


 

Bestseller No. 1
Weiman Leather Cleaner, Conditioner & Protector, Car Interior & Furniture
11,047 Reviews
Weiman Leather Cleaner, Conditioner & Protector, Car Interior & Furniture
  • Cleaning & conditioning: Powerful leather cleaner and conditioner that removes dirt, oils, grime, and residue while restoring natural suppleness and improving the look and feel of leather furniture, car seatseBay logo, couches, sofas, jackets, handbags, shoes, saddles, and tack. This cleaning leather treatment nourishes and revitalizes finished leather surfaces, helping maintain softness and long-lasting protection
  • UV protection to prevent cracking: Provides advanced UV protection for leather, helping prevent fading, drying, discoloration, and cracking caused by sunlight exposure. This leather protector shields car leather seats, leather furniture, couches, and handbags to maintain long-lasting color and durability
  • Works on all finished leather: Safe and effective on all finished leather surfaces, including car interiors, leather couches, sofas, recliners, office chairs, jackets, handbags, boots, shoes, baseball mitt, horse tack, and accessories. Also suitable as a faux leather cleaner and conditioner, making it a versatile solution for home and automotive leather care
  • No sticky residue: Leaves no greasy residue, making it suitable for leather restoration, leather maintenance, and routine conditioning
  • Premium Leather Care: Trusted by millions for high-quality leather cleaning and conditioning, Weiman delivers professional-grade results for car leather care, leather furniture maintenance, and everyday leather restoration. A reliable, long-lasting leather care solution backed by decades of expertise
SaleBestseller No. 2
Leather Honey Leather Cleaner โ€“ Non-Toxic & Made in the USA Since 1968
33,475 Reviews
Leather Honey Leather Cleaner – Non-Toxic & Made in the USA Since 1968
  • NON TOXIC, GENTLE CLEANER: Our proven, rejuvenating formula is a powerful, fragrance-free cleaner ideal for all your leather goods (except suede). EPA Safer Choice certified
  • CLEAN ALL TYPES OF LEATHER: Quickly and gently removes dirt, oil, tough stains and grime from car seatseBay logo, truck seats, upholstery, furniture, handbags, purses, shoes, accessories, saddles, and tack. Effectively cleans leather of all colors, including white leather. Safe for exotic leather, faux, vinyl
  • SAFE FOR YOU, SAFE FOR LEATHER: Made with non-toxic, high-quality ingredients that makes your leather last longer. Safe for people, pets & your leather
  • TEST & APPLY: Apply leather cleaner with a lint-free cloth. No need to scrub or rub — simply wipe down and allow it to dry. Spot test on each leather item first. Not for use on suede
  • AMERICAN MADE SINCE 1968: Our premium leather care formulas have had a cult following among leather experts, retailers and high-end car and furniture makers and enthusiasts for over 50 years.
Bestseller No. 3
Chemical Guys, Leather Cleaner & Conditioner Kit for Cars & Home, 2 x 16 oz
  • COMPLETE LEATHER CARE KIT (SPI_109_16) - This Chemical Guys kit includes Cleaner and Conditioner, two 16 oz bottles that work together to clean, restore, and protect leather in cars, homes, and more
  • CLEANS AND CONDITIONS - Chemical Guys interior cleaner for leather that lifts dirt and grime while the Conditioner nourishes and restores leather suppleness, leaving interior surfaces soft, smooth, refreshed
  • VERSATILE USE - This car leather cleaner and conditioner kit is designed for automotive interiors and equally effective on leather furniture, apparel, shoes, boots, jackets, handbags, and other everyday leather goods
  • SAFE & EFFECTIVE CAR LEATHER CONDITIONER AND CLEANER- pH-balanced formulas are safe for all natural, synthetic, and sealed leathers; gentle cleaning power helps prevent cracks, fading, and drying while preserving the original finish
  • EASY TWO-STEP SYSTEM - Use this Leather Cleaner for car interiors to remove embedded dirt, then apply Leather Conditioner to hydrate and protect; achieve professional results at home or in your garage
Bestseller No. 4
Chemical Guys, Colorless & Odorless Leather Cleaner, Car Interiors, 16 oz
  • COLORLESS & ODORLESS LEATHER CLEANER (SPI_208_16) – Chemical Guys leather cleaner gently cleans leather surfaces without dyes or scents, lifting dirt, oils, and embedded dirt while preserving the natural look and feel
  • SAFE FOR ALL LEATHER TYPES – A leather cleaner for car interiors, natural, synthetic, faux, and pleather; ideal for furniture, boots, jackets, handbags, and more
  • REMOVES DIRT & GRIME – This car leather cleaner breaks down body oils, food spills, dust, and daily buildup without leaving residue, streaks, or causing discoloration
  • PREPS FOR CONDITIONING – This Chemical Guys interior cleaner for cars and leather furniture cleaner is the perfect first step before applying a leather conditioner or protectant to maintain durability, suppleness, and appearance
  • EASY TO USE – Spray directly on leather, as a leather car seateBay logo cleaner, or onto a microfiber applicator, gently scrub with a soft brush, and wipe clean for refreshed, clean leather
Bestseller No. 5
Armor All Car Leather Cleaner Spray with Beeswax, 16 Fl Oz
  • Nourish leather with real beeswax in Armor All Leather Care With Beeswax. Real beeswax for leather is blended into this spray cleaner to preserve leather's supple feel. Designed as a car upholstery cleaner, this leather spray cleans, conditions and protects. The leather cleaner removes dirt and soil to effectively clean the grain. The leather conditioner restores the supple feel and rich beauty. Finally, leather protectant helps protect against drying, aging and cracking. Apply the car interior cleaner to your car's leather surfaces to revive that luxurious look and provide lasting protection.
  • One 16 fl oz bottle of Armor All Leather Care With Beeswax
  • Spray formula with real beeswax to nourish leather
  • Removes dirt and soil to effectively clean the grain
  • Conditions to restore supple feel and natural beauty

This product presentation was made with AAWP plugin.

Leave a Comment

Share to...